This fandom is very tricky. There is a distinct divide between what I've been calling "Tolkien" and what I've been labeling "LOTR." And that divide seems to be based on the movies. "Tolkien" technically covers everything (all the books, all the movies) and I'd vote for having that cat on everything, and then having LOTR Movies as a subcategory, which itself would be broken down further as necessary. Not sure what to do about "The Hobbit" movie when it comes out.

Thank you for the poetry cat.