Sequential Art&Animation would need subcategories For Anime & Manga and Comics because both are big enough to need their own cats. But then there wouldn't be any pages/files left for the SA&A cat! That would go against Fanlore's best practice when it comes to categories. To me it makes more sense to have an Anime & Manga *and* a Comics cat *instead* of a SA&A.
Fandom by Source Community has currently three subcats: Furry, German-Speaking Fandom, and Science Fiction. All of them with several pages and files. None of them part of your structure?
As I've already said, I think Anime & Manga and Comics belong under Fandoms by Canon Type. RPF is Real People Fiction so I don't see what the difference between RPF and Real People is supposed to be. That's not a useful distinction. For what it's worth, I see it as a canon type thing.
Media Fandom is completely useless as a category for anything because everything can be Media Fandom and if it's not now, it could be in the future. Harry & Johnny was media fandom, Eroica was/is media fandom, and even Popslash is media fandom because it follows in that tradition. It's a glossary term and explains so much about our history (multimedia zines anyone?), but it doesn't work as a category that people add to pages and files, which is what categories are for.
J-pop is Real People and K-Drama is Television? Film? So these would be subcategories of the Fandom by canon type cats. The "pages" explaining what J-pop/K-Drama/Mediafandom, etc. is could stay under fandom by community, but that is not the same as creating fandom by community cats and then adding all the respective fandom cats to these categories.
no subject
Sequential Art&Animation would need subcategories For Anime & Manga and Comics because both are big enough to need their own cats. But then there wouldn't be any pages/files left for the SA&A cat! That would go against Fanlore's best practice when it comes to categories. To me it makes more sense to have an Anime & Manga *and* a Comics cat *instead* of a SA&A.
Fandom by Source Community has currently three subcats: Furry, German-Speaking Fandom, and Science Fiction. All of them with several pages and files. None of them part of your structure?
As I've already said, I think Anime & Manga and Comics belong under Fandoms by Canon Type. RPF is Real People Fiction so I don't see what the difference between RPF and Real People is supposed to be. That's not a useful distinction. For what it's worth, I see it as a canon type thing.
Media Fandom is completely useless as a category for anything because everything can be Media Fandom and if it's not now, it could be in the future. Harry & Johnny was media fandom, Eroica was/is media fandom, and even Popslash is media fandom because it follows in that tradition. It's a glossary term and explains so much about our history (multimedia zines anyone?), but it doesn't work as a category that people add to pages and files, which is what categories are for.
J-pop is Real People and K-Drama is Television? Film? So these would be subcategories of the Fandom by canon type cats. The "pages" explaining what J-pop/K-Drama/Mediafandom, etc. is could stay under fandom by community, but that is not the same as creating fandom by community cats and then adding all the respective fandom cats to these categories.